Secret Message Personalized Collar Stays Set of 3 Customer Reviews

I had ordered these collar stays for my husband for our 25th anniversary 4 years ago. He loved them. They were good quality and came in a very nice velvet box. Our son is graduating from college and he will be wearing dress shirts every day so we thought this would be a nice graduation gift. And we thought it would be the same quality. But things have changed. The collar stays are much thinner and the gift box is just a cardboard box. We were disappointed because we were expecting the same quality as before.

We just ordered these for our son's college graduation and we were disappointed when they arrived because they weren't nearly as nice as when I ordered them for my husband 4 years ago. My husband's came in a very nice velvet hinged box, satin lined. The collar stays were thicker also and in general, just nicer. These arrive in a box with lid and not as nice. We assumed they would be the same.

Flimsy metal, but my guy appreciated the personalized messages. Lettering and punctuation was all accurate.

These are pretty and a wonderful keepsake idea for any major milestone. Unfortunately they are too long for a standard collar and my friend wasn't able to wear these on his wedding day. The description didn't mention this and the shop refused to acknowledge that the collar stays are too long and it's not mentioned.

I bought these for my husband for Christmas. They are cute, but they aren't the standard size. They are not wide enough, so they fall out of the shirt collar easily.

The color stays are nice, but one was stained. The personalization is quite difficult to read: not as clear as in picture on website.