Deserves 5 Stars but they arrived with fingerprints and needed polishingThese are marvelous and amazing. The engraving was perfect and they are heavy and quite well-made. I would order them again. I sent these off to all my friends who just had baby's and those recently married and engaged. They loved them. Didn't think they were cheesy and said they would remain part of their holiday traditions and dressings for all their lives. I recommend that you take them out of the wrap and review them. Couple of the ones I shipped, the receivers mentioned were smudged with fingerprints. Other than that - excellent product for the price. Delivered on time and look fantastic on the tree.