Our guests loved them! We used these as our favors for our wedding for the guests to take home. They all loved them, and my husband and I as well. They smelled great, they were the perfect size, they came in a timely fashion... I dont have anything negative to say except maybe I should have bought more. We actually bought extras but my husband and I almost didn't even get any, luckily my mom had grabbed a couple extras and gave us 2, but everyone we have talked to since said they were grabbing as many as they could because they enjoyed them so much.