Personalized Gifts & Personalized Gift Ideas

Shop By Price

  • under $20
  • $20-$30
  • $30-$50
  • $50+
  • Top Pick

    Free Personalization – No gimmicks or hidden fees. Personalization is what we do best so we offer that service to you free of charge.

    Fast Turnaround – Even though we make each gift custom for you, we don’t want to keep you waiting. Most of our gifts ship out in just 1-2 days!

    #1 in Quality Merchandise – Our gifts are meant to last. We select only the finest materials so that the gifts you give today will be treasured for life.

    100% Satisfaction Guaranteed – We work hard to make sure your gift is personalized exactly as you requested it. We guarantee that your product will be accurate and free from defects in quality and in workmanship.

    Customer Testimonial
    Thank you so much for the beautiful items I received in the mail. I loved everthing - very professional, very fast, and I am very happy. You have a return customer!
    ~Lois - NJ

    Initially Yours Self-Inking Address Stamper customer reviews

    Self-Inking Personalized Address Stamper - Initially Yours - 5185
    Average Customer Review: (33 customer reviews)
    Share your thoughts with other customers:
    5 star:
    4 star:
    3 star:
    2 star:
    1 star:

    Showing 1-star reviews › See all reviews
    Sort reviews by:
    Print Too Small
    By Sarah V. This customer has purchased this item prior to writing this review. (Greenville, NC) - January 14, 2014 (See all reviews by this customer)
    I am very disappointed with the size of the print after I stamped it the first time. I had to hold it up close to tell what it says. :(
    print too small
    By Doreen I. This customer has purchased this item prior to writing this review. (Lancaster, PA) - February 13, 2012 (See all reviews by this customer)
    I ordered this return address stamp and the print is so small, you can barely read it. Not happy at all. Will probably throw it away and buy one somewhere else.
    Not acceptable
    By Shopper This customer has purchased this item prior to writing this review. (Warwick, NY) - August 15, 2011
    This is the 2nd stamper we have ordered from Both stampers were ordered as gifts and both came with errors. This stamper had various fonts on each of the lines and was extremely small and hard to read. I would not recommend ordering stampers from this site.
    Not the usual quality
    By Sarah S. This customer has purchased this item prior to writing this review. (Warwick, NY) - December 17, 2010 (See all reviews by this customer)
    I have ordered a few items from Personalization Mall before and have always been pleased with the quality. However, this self-inking stamper was off center and the bottom line of the address was not fully on the stamp. I contacted their customer service and did receive a prompt reply. After having to send in various pictures of the defective item, PM agreed to send me a new stamper (at no cost). I was pleased with their customer service but very disappointed in what was obviously a poor excuse for a stamper.
    © 1998-2014 All Rights Reserved