I Thank God Personalized Baptism Keepsake

4.5

star rating

5 Stars

25

4 Stars

5

3 Stars

3

2 Stars

0

1 Stars

2

Customers say:

Customers generally find the personalized baptism keepsake to be a beautiful and meaningful gift, praised for its quality, elegance, and sentimentality. However, some noted disappointment with the size being smaller than expected and a few issues with the etching quality. Despite these concerns, the item is frequently recommended and well-received for its timeless appeal and prompt delivery.

PREV
Page 1 of 1
Sort by:
star rating

Special Remembrance

Anonymous Hutto, TX | 4/25/2024

View all Reviews by Charmaine L.

I purchased a keepsake for a friend to note how special her baptism will be (coming in May). I love the baptism keepsake!! It has her name, a cross, and the date on it. It looks great!! She will always have this to remember that special life changing day. It’s just the right size to put on the mantle, dresser, or even her desk at work. The encouraging words that are etched on the plaque are so special too. I know she is going to love this!!!

star rating

Adult Bapt

Lois P. North Royalton, OH | 9/8/2023

View all Reviews by Lois P.

We usually baptize babies at my church. We have a young 20+ adult, who thankfully wanted to be baptized. We usually do a banner for an infant, but I wanted something special for this young lady. This is perfect!

star rating

Better Than expected

Anonymous Wallingford, CT | 3/29/2023

View all Reviews by Leigh W.

Received very fast. Engraving is good quality. Very impressive

star rating

Happy baptismal day!

Anonymous Utica, NY | 10/22/2022

View all Reviews by Sandra S.

I bought this for my grandson for his baptism last year and it was such a perfect gift I bought another for this upcoming baptism for grandson #4.<br/><br/><br/>

star rating

Perfect for the occasion

Gina W. Apple Valley, MN | 8/20/2022

View all Reviews by Gina W.

An older child was being baptized & I was looking for a meaningful keepsake that wasn't too large, but still showed celebration. This was exactly what I was looking for

star rating

Baptism keepsake

Deidre A. Lampasas, TX | 1/8/2021

View all Reviews by Deidre A.

It’s beautiful!

star rating

Great gift

Donna S. Monterey, CA | 2/23/2020

View all Reviews by Donna S.

This is just what I was hoping for. I ordered it for my daughters baptism as a keepsake. It turned out beautiful!

star rating

Perfect gift

Christina R. Tulsa, OK | 4/12/2019

View all Reviews by Christina R.

I didn't realize how small it was but it was beautiful! My daughter loved it!

star rating

Wonderful!

Anonymous round rock, TX | 4/2/2019

View all Reviews by Christina H.

Live it

star rating

Grandson's gift

Anonymous Oviedo, FL | 2/21/2017

View all Reviews by Patricia M.

I purchased this beautiful keepsake for my grandson's baptism. It was also his 8th birthday so he received many gifts. He told his Mom it was the best gift he got. I was happy he liked it. It's beautiful and I would definitely recommend it.

star rating

Twin Treasures

Rosemarie M. Granville, IL | 12/15/2016

View all Reviews by Rosemarie M.

My twin grandbabies were born 3 months too soon and spent almost 4 months in the NICU, then a 1600m. drive to come home to family. They were recently baptized, so I was searching for a gift to commemorate the occasion. The loving verse that is inscribed on this plaque is just beautiful and couldn't be more appropriate. It is truly a wonderful keepsake for them to treasure their whole lives.

star rating

Wonderful

Anonymous Enders, NE | 5/8/2016

View all Reviews by Jodi S.

We got this plaque to commemorate our sons baptism. He loves it. It's a good quality and very nice looking.

star rating

Baptism

Gail M. Grand Prairie , TX | 2/28/2016

View all Reviews by Gail M.

This acrylic block with name and date signifies the day my wonderful grand daughter was baptized. She is tiny and I am old. God blesses her and I want the date to be remembered as easily as possible. I love the small block with her name, date and her give name.

star rating

Very Pleased With My Order!

Anonymous FAIRACRES, NM | 2/20/2016

View all Reviews by MARTHA P.

I was extremely pleased with my order! It was very high quality and shipping was super quick! I would definitely order other items from Personalization Mall again!

star rating

Makes a great keepsake gift

Heather H. Ashwaubenon, WI | 9/22/2015

View all Reviews by Heather H.

I've purchased this particular piece for three separate baptismal gifts. It's been well received by the families - it's classic, timeless and small to easily move and display. Very happy with each purchase. Quick ordering and fast delivery

star rating

Perfect gift

Anonymous Cottonwood, AZ | 5/2/2015

View all Reviews by Diane O.

This was purchased as a baptism gift for my newly adopted grandson. It's the perfect keepsake to remind him he was a part of our family since the moment he entered our lives and will now forever be a child of God. Excellent quality with a beautiful verse.

star rating

Baptism Keepsake

Anonymous Hanley Falls, MN | 8/25/2014

View all Reviews by Bonnie O.

This is really a nice keepsake

star rating

REMARKABLE

MICHAEL J. CHICAGO, IL | 3/3/2014

View all Reviews by MICHAEL J.

Remarkable, fast delivery and accurately done with perfection !

star rating

Baptism Gift

Anonymous South Elgin, IL | 8/4/2013

View all Reviews by Aimee P.

The Personalized Baptism Keepsake was for my great nephew. I wanted something that he would have for the rest of his life, and a gift that the Baptism date on it to be a special keepsake. Both his parents loved the gift and like the poem that was engraved behind his name. A very special gift that was perfect! The keepsake arrived in perfect condition, the name and date were correct, no complaints... perfect!<br/>

star rating

Perfect

Elizabeth S. Los Angeles , CA | 2/8/2013

View all Reviews by Elizabeth S.

I didn't know what to get for my niece, for her baptism. I was looking for something that she coulp keep forver. This keepsake will definitely last forever. I love it, and I hope she will too.

star rating

great christening gift

Suzanne N. Long Grove, IL | 4/15/2011

View all Reviews by Suzanne N.

beautiful gift for a baptism. they arrived ahead of schedule in a high quality box with a pretty silver ribbon. The prayer is lovely. The gift receiver loved them and found them to be one of her favorite gifts. I would defintely purchase again for a baptism gift.

star rating

walk with jesus

Sandra T. Spring Hill, FL | 3/14/2011

View all Reviews by Sandra T.

There are very few adult baptism items that you can buy. This item that I bought was way beyond my expectations. My adult daughter was baptised recently, and she absolutely LOVED it. The personalization was exquisite and made both my daughter and I cry. Thank you so much for putting such care in your items. God bless.

star rating

Great quality for the price!

Sarah M. Pearland, TX | 9/16/2010

View all Reviews by Sarah M.

I just ordered these for 2 of my daughters who are getting baptized! Got them within a week and are nice, heavy quality! I'll be proud to give them and have them displayed in their bedrooms!

star rating

Great Baptism Gift

Jennifer H. Fishers, IN | 6/1/2010

View all Reviews by Jennifer H.

I had 2 nephews baptized in May and bought one for each. I love the saying and the fact it could be made special by personalizing it with the name and date of baptism. I am very pleased with the quality of the piece as well as the engraving. It is also packaged nicely to be given a gift. The only thing I didn't like was the large printed label on the bottom of the black box. While I understand the need for it, I think it takes away from the classiness of the box. I wish it could be a removable label.<br/>I think it will be a nice keepsake item for both families! I gave it to my sister last week and she LOVED it!

star rating

Gorgeous keepsake

Lisa C. Lakemoor, IL | 12/17/2009

View all Reviews by Lisa C.

This item came very nicely wrapped and is truly a beautiful gift

star rating

excited

Patti H. Belgium, WI | 9/23/2018

View all Reviews by Patti H.

I was excited when I read the words behind my grandson's name, etc. However, the stand, or anything that holds it, makes reading the words a little cumbersome.

star rating

Baptism

Debi P. Troy, OH | 5/7/2018

View all Reviews by Debi P.

The squares were smaller than what I thought. The work and on the item was beautiful. Just needed to be larger.

star rating

Baptism Keepsake

Anonymous Frankfort, NY | 9/6/2016

View all Reviews by Susan M.

Very nice item. A nice keepsake. The prayer was perfect for a baptism.<br/>Would purchase again

star rating

Nicely done Baptismal paper weight

JoeAnn H. Severna Park, MD | 9/16/2012

View all Reviews by JoeAnn H.

This "paperweight" was very well done...there was just enough spaces for my granddaughter's very long name and it looks rather elegant. It is smaller than I imagined and there's no way to hang it. I'm afraid it might fall over if left standing on one end, so laying it down flat like a paperweight is best. Perhaps it would look nice in a small easel. The verse written behind it is lovely, though the Bible reference isn't written on it anywhere and would be nice to have on it. Putting it on a dark background makes it easier to read. I'm not sure how my son and his wife will use or display it, but I personally think it's pretty nice looking....for a paperweight.

star rating

beautiful!

Jennifer C. Lake Orion, MI | 7/5/2011

View all Reviews by Jennifer C.

I was "iffy" on ordering this product, but it exceeded my expectations. It's nice and heavy, great quality. The engraving was done beautifully and I love the sentimental poem. Arrived very quickly and was nicely boxed. A beautiful keepsake for my nephew's baptism.

star rating

misleading ad

MARK L. USA | 1/4/2025

View all Reviews by MARK L.

your picture in your ad shows that you can read the wording, only because you have a colored background. upon receiving the item, it is very hard to read the saying as we are not using a background. It's pretty, but disappointed

star rating

Product Baptism Keepsake

Carla R. Silver Spring, MD | 12/11/2024

View all Reviews by Carla R.

The item was smaller than I expected. I thought an item that was ordered by my church last year was larger than the one I ordered. I don’t recall reading measurements. Nonetheless it will be a nice keepsake. Received in a timely fashion & inscription was perfect.

star rating

Baptismal gift

Anonymous Twin Lake, MI | 12/9/2020

View all Reviews by Carrie K.

I ordered two of these baptismal gifts for my two grandchildren. In the picture, I thought it was adorable. However, after I received them, I did not think that they were worth what I paid for them. The first one that I ordered was $34.00. Then, because of giving this gift to one grandchild, I had to order another so the other grandchild's feelings did not get hurt. When I ordered the second one, it was on sale so, I paid less money for it. The first one that I ordered, I had to pay $34.00 when the cost of the item was only $19.99. I feel that I got ripped off with the shipping and handling. Therefore, I feel the cost of the item along with the shipping and handling was way too much!

star rating

Didn't realize the product was so small

Rich P. Tega Cay, SC | 3/17/2023

View all Reviews by Rich P.

My bad...I didn't realize how small this keepsake was...really disappointed...

star rating

etching quality

Cheryl R. Melrose, MN | 11/27/2010

View all Reviews by Cheryl R.

I was very dissapointed with the quality of the etching, with some letters in name very hard to read..Different shades of etching....Would send back if I had time and will not purchase through this site again