|
sabretx By Shopper (McKinney, TX) - February 5, 2011 You say to rate the product only, but when a I buy an item I buy for the over all look. I would of given 5 stars, but engraving was not impressive enough.
|
Perfect Gift The Engraved Siler Cigar Case & Cutter Set was an awesome anniverary gift for my husband. After being married for thirteen years I just wasn't sure what to get him. He has everything. So I came across this item and my first thought was wow, here's something he'll actually make use of. It won't be shoved into a closet or jewelry box. I was so pleased as to how quickly the item shipped. Arrived in plenty of time. I was impressed withthe quality of this item as well.
|
ALMOST perfect! My husband was so happy when he opened this for Father's Day. They are both beautiful quality and the engraving was perfect. The only problem was the cigars that he smokes didn't fit in the case. It is just a little too small. He's trying to find cigars that are a little smaller.
|
case and cutter set the inscription on the cutter is hard to see.
|
Beautiful, but a little too narrow. Both products turned out beautifully and are of a very good quality. Just as many of the other reviews on here said, the cigar case is pretty narrow. I'm hoping my husband will be able to find cigars he likes that will fit in it. I have not given it to him yet but I think he'll love it and hope the size of it won't be too big of a deal.
|
Good gift I bought this as a gift for my boyfriend and loved it when it came in the mail, but I was sad to find out that his favorite type of cigar didn't fit in the case. It's a beautiful case for thinner cigars though.
|
Perfect Gift This item was a perfect gift for my boyfriend. I was not expecting such great quality. Note that the cigar case holds only thin cigars. That was an overlook on my part. Other than that great quality at a great price!
|
As a gift Got this for my boyfriend for v-day and he loved it! Great gift :-)
|
Sleek Stogey accessories The personalized cigar case and cutter set is really nice. I had yet to find both pieces, of this quality, for such an affordable price. When I checked on personalizationmall.com and and found the "set" on sale, I ordered it right away! It was even nicer than the picture when it arrived (within just a few days). Love it and so will my husband!
|
Good value The cutter was not as nice as I thought it would be, but overall great value. They both looked very nice.
|
D in Dallas I puchased for my son and husband for Christmas...They both thought the case was beautiful and good quality. the only problem is that there's not very many cigars that fit in the case. Only the small cigars. Inside of the tube in not as big as it appears on the outside...So they are not really able to use...I was disappointed...
|
Diameter too small. It is a beautiful holder, especially with the engraving. However, the cigar holder will only hold a small diameter cigar.
|
Very nice, stylish, sophisticated This item was purchased for my boss for Christmas. He is a very picky person and has high tastes. He was thrilled with the gift and thought it looked really nice and professional. The quality seemed very nice, not cheap or thin. It was very well received.
|
cigar case the engraving the cigar case itself i was happy with, I just didn't realize it don't fit all sizes of cigars, it only fits the smaller size cigars, but other than that I was happy with it..
|
nice They both look nice. It is hard to find a cigar that fits in the case so it is almost useless.
|
Great Set But the cigar case holds only a slim caigar. Torpedos and Churchills will not fit. Nicely engraved, though.
|
Cigar Case to small I ordered this for my husband. When he received it he was happy with the cigar cutter. He also like the Cirgar case but wish it was wider to fix fatter cigars. The Case is good for thin size cigar. Man usually like to smoke the bigger cigars. the engraving was very nice. One more thing the shipping I would have rather it would have shipped via ups or fed-ex cause its much eaiser to track.
|
Engraved Cigar holder My husband loved it! Only wish that the ring was a little bigger, but it fits most of his cigars. Great to have.
|
Adequate Very nice engraving on a fairly cheap cutter. Adequate for the price
|
Personalization is messed up The etching on the cutter isn't even.
|
Nice but pricy By Shopper (norwalk, CA) - May 30, 2016 It looks nice but also cheaply made. The case isn't very thick, meaning that it'll bend very easily. My husband likes it but I wouldn't buy it again if I had to. The price just wasn't worth it.
|
Not for large gauge cigars This looks nice and was exactly what I wanted to get my husband BUT it is useless for his large gauge cigars-- to include cutter. If you smoke skinny cigars, this will work. I wish they offered additional sizes, I am disappointed that he won't be able to use his gift as often.
|
Samscigar case Nicely made; personalization well done; but thought the case was for small cigars; disappointed in that.
|
great gift,my dad loved it. nice and simple gift.
|
Not to thrilled .... By Shopper (Miami, FL) - June 2, 2013 The case and engraving are really nice, BUT is really hard to open,...Had to put lots of oil and let it seat in order for it to open...Now I will have to clean it really well because is for a gift and it will be very disappointing to the receiver to have oil smell in a tobacco case...:/
|
Beautiful engraving Both pieces in this set look great. My boyfriend was really impressed to see his name & initials on the irtems when he opened the set. Font size is great, easy to make out whats written. The only questionable part is how difficult it is to open the tube & slide the cutter closed.... You have to twist & pull & twist & pull & pull some more to get the tube to come open. & the cutter, we haven't used it on a cigar yet, but its definitely not smooth opening & closing it while empty. I think we're going to oil both pieces & hopefully that will be all that's needed to get them broken in! Overall a great product for the cost.
|
Extremely great customer support By Shopper (Hoopeston, IL) - December 11, 2012 The product itself is just ok. It's very pretty and the personalization is a great touch but it doesn't appear to be exceptionally functional. I imagine after a couple dozen cigars this cutter is going to get dull and stop working but it will still look nice. The thing that impresses me is their customer service. I had a problem with the original cutter I ordered and the person I talked to fixed it right away, was so nice and professional, and never questioned me. It was wonderful to have such a great customer service experience.
|
Great looking, less feeling By Shopper (Baltimore, MD) - October 24, 2011 I ordered this as a anniversary gift, both items engraved. They look absolutely amazing, and are lightweight. The cutter isn't as high in quality as I thought it would be, and seems cheaply maunfatured. However, my guy was extremely happy with his gift, which made me happy. Just hoping it holds up well enough to not just be a keepsake...
|
cigar bop This item is neat! the Cigar holder is biger then i expected but the personalization was not as eay to see as i would have liked. I would have also liked to have a font choise.
|
Nice, but Engraved Poorly By Shopper (Red Hook, NY) - May 9, 2011 My fiance wanted a case that could hold a big cigar. Unfortunately it can only hold a medium sized cigar. Thats not horrible, but the engraving was done so lightly that I could hardly see his name. The gift was a nice idea, he loved it, but I think that the engraving could have been done better.
|
engraving By Shopper (LOS ANGELES, CA) - April 28, 2011 I like them but, the engraving is not apparent. It is hard to see it.
|
Cigar Case I think this item is a good gift idea. I am quite disappointed in the quality of the lid on the cigar case as I had to have a 2nd one shipped to me because it was peeling on the inside, giving it a tarnished look and the 2nd on was the same way. I will say the 2nd one was a lot less obvious. It is something that can be overlooked, but perfection is something that I look for when purchasing gifts.
|
Ring Gage This is a beautiful set and a great gift but the ring gage of the cigar case is not 50. It is more 40 ring gage.
|
Not impressed The engraving is so light you can hardly see it.
|
Monogram is disappointing The weight & quality of the cigar case itself seem great, but the monogramming is so small & lightly sketched, its almost invisible. I’m very disappointed with the monogram quality which is the focal point of the item.
|
fair review By Shopper (Tucson, AZ) - May 17, 2016 my only reason for a "fair" review is that when i went to order these items, they were half off yet i was charged the full price, even when i emailed customer service they would not give me a refund. it's a nice set. just make sure you're paying what you think you are.
|
quality of engraving By Shopper (Winston-Salem, NC) - December 11, 2015 Cigar case was larger than I expected but quite sturdy. My big issue is the quality of the engraving. It is just lightly etched into the case and hardly visible. I had to turn it over several times to see where it had been engraved. Letters were also smaller than show in photo. I deeper cut would have made this a nice gift, but this was disappointing. it looks nothing like the preview shot
|
okay By Shopper (Lynden, WA) - February 11, 2015 I bought this for my husband as a gift. He really liked the cutter but wasn't crazy about the cigar case. We could not even get the case open. We pulled and pulled and twisted and twisted but could not get the darn thing open! Got a good laugh though. Even if it did open he still would rather have a cigar box instead. So the cutter a hit, the case a miss.
|
Engraving By Shopper (Rapid City, SD) - June 16, 2013 I was disappointed on the engraving on the Cigar case. It does show clearly. You have to really look for it.
|
Engraving is Poor on item It was a great thought but the engraving is so POOR that you can barely see it. you have to hold it perfectly under light to see the name on both pieces. it wouldn't even hold metal paint to bring out the engraving because the engraving isn't deep enough
|