I loved the set and would have given it a "5" except the engraving on the pen was not as visible as I would have liked. Perhaps my fault as I chose a font (cursive) that was not conducive to a deeper and more visible text. But, the case was excellent and due to the space available, able to be engraved very visibly. With the small circumference available on the pen, a bolder font should have been used--wish I had been advised of this by the professionals. The recipient loved the set in its entirety.