Mixed feeling.The rose itself is amazing. The vase is a little small but nice. The engraving is small and light colored but does make it better no matter what you. My problem is with the gift box. Excuse my language but it sucks way too big for the rose and vase. It shouldn't have the logo in my opinion. Back to the size of the box. Am I supposed to put the vase with all the padding? I'll have to throw the box away and go with the vase and rose separately.