SHOP BY:

Occasion

Search In:

Father's Day Gifts

2025

Father's Day Gift Guide

For New Dads

First Father's Day Gift Ideas For New Dads

Dad's very first Father's Day is a truly special occasion. Commemorate this important milestone with one of these thoughtful and meaningful gifts for new Dads. Make his first Father's Day more memorable with a custom picture frame with a precious photo of baby and Daddy, or engrave baby's birthdate on a pocket token just for Dad.

Personalize our fun set of beer labels for a six-pack Dad will never forget, or create a photo mug, canvas print, shelf blocks and other photo gifts that feature photos of his little bundle of joy. Browse Father's Day gifts for first-time Dads and new Dads to find inspiration and ideas to create the perfect Father's Day presents.

Shop Our Top Picks

First Father's Day Picture Frame

Help the new Dad remember his first very Father's Day with a beautiful, custom picture frame and one of his favorite photos of baby and Daddy. Add your custom message at the top, along with baby's name and year to be printed on the bottom of the frame. Choose from 2 frame sizes and orientations. This beautiful rustic shiplap frame will be one Father's Day gift the first time Dad will hold on to forever.

Personalize It Now

First Father's Day Baby Outfit

Make his very first Father's Day a day to remember by dressing up his little bundle of joy in a cute outfit with a fun message. This Daddy, You're Doing A Great Job baby clothes collection is a great choice and will make the perfect accessory for a memorable photo of the new Daddy and baby. Customize the outfit of your choice with a special message Dad won't ever forget.

Personalize It Now

New Dad Beer Labels

Let the new Dad proudly proclaim his new title with our embroidered Baseball Cap. Choose a white or black cap, embroidered with any name or title, along with any optional year, in your choice of thread color. The perfect way to top off his outfit, especially on Father’s Day!

Personalize It Now

Engraved Heart Pocket Token

Give Dad a first Father's Day gift he will never forget. Our custom engraved pocket token is something the new Dad can keep with him always. Add baby's name, birthdate or a special message for Dad so he'll always remember this day. The coin sized pocket token includes a heart-shaped cutout so it can be strung on a chain and worn as a pendant.

Personalize It Now

Custom Photo Coffee Mug

Put those newborn photos to good use and create a custom photo coffee mug for the new Dad to use every day! Choose from many mug designs you can customize with your own photos and a special message just for Dad. You can also choose between classic ceramic mugs and insulated travel mugs with one or multiple photo options. This will be one coffee mug Dad will treasure for many years.

Personalize It Now

DAD Photo Shelf Blocks

Create a beautiful reminder of how lucky he is to be a Dad with three of your favorite photos printed on this unique set of shelf blocks. The semi-transparent letters "D-A-D" are printed across the front of the photos in a beautiful, unique font. Use full color or black and white photos for a dramatic effect. This might very well become the new Dad's favorite piece of home decor in your house!

Personalize It Now