Fees and surcharges may apply. Offer available online and by telephone only. Offer not available in corporate store. Offers cannot be combined and are not available on all products and are subject to restrictions and limitations. Offer ends 7/6/25. Prices and charges are subject to change without notice. Void where prohibited.
The majority of customers praised the product for being beautiful, well-made, and having high-quality engraving. However, some mentioned issues with size, such as being smaller than expected, as well ... see more
Nice item but engraving was off center - twice!
By Shopper (Columbus, OH) - May 2, 2011
This is a nice little gift for a first communicant however the engraving was not centered. Customer service was great at facilitating a no hassle replacement (all I had to do was send a picture by email)however the replacement was only slightly better. At this point I have to give the gift, and it's still off center, but I guess this is as good as it gets.
I first ordered the sterling silver and swavorski chrystal cross necklace as a gift for my 8-year-old niece's first communion; I was disappointed that it did not come in a nice presentation box. So, I ordered the Holy Day Rosary Case to hold the necklace; that way, the gift could be personalized with the recipient's name and date.
The rosary case is the perfect size for my purpose. I liked the weight and hinge function of this case. And the case comes in a nice presentation box.
However, the engraving is very faint and the surface quickly shows fingerprints when handled. I made the mistake of gently rubbing the case on my fleece jogging suit to remove fingerprints and this resulted in some scratching-- before the gift was even given. Because of these points, I would not order this case again.
This was a nice gift idea but the engraving was kind of sloppy -- a little lopsided and off center. I don't have any more time to order a new one, so I will give it anyway. But I have to say I was a little disappointed. I had a problem once before with personalization with a throw I had done for my Grandmother. I think you have to be careful what you get from this site.
I love the box but was disappointed when I got it and there was no cross in it. I went back to the website to see if it said that it was not included. It did say that, I guess I over looked it. Maybe it could be bolder or something.
I wanted to like the rosary case more, but there were a few problems. The case looks nice in the picture, but in reality it is light and cheap looking. The website picture showing the open lid appears as though the entire interior is lined, but it's not. The only lining is a thin blue fabric inside on the bottom. The sides are bare metal. My biggest disappointment has to do with the engraving. The engraving is shallow, but more importantly, it was slightly crooked. I chose the cross design and the top of the cross pointed slightly to the left when compared to the hinge at the top of the box. All in all, disappointed.
I was very excited about this product as a gift for my niece, but when I received it the engraving on the top was so faint you could hardly read it. I contacted customer service and all they told me was that was the best it could be done and I could return it for store credit. The display picture is very deceiving.
Dissappointed
By Shopper (Westwood, MA) - March 31, 2011
I am only rating this 2 stars because of the engraving. It is so light that you can barely read it. I am so disappointed. If the engraving was done properly, I would have rated this 5 stars.
Seems like plastic
By Shopper (Brooklyn, MI) - April 28, 2014
I ordered one of these cases for my daughter's First Communion and was very pleased....so pleased that I came back 4 years later to order the same one for my son. This new case is not even close to the quality of the last one. It seems more like plastic than metal (though I was informed that it is 'plated steel' when I unsuccessfully requested a refund). If it's steel, it's a very thin layer of steel coating something like plastic. I do not recommend this box.
Loading cart contents...
192 reviews
20 reviews
154 reviews
Nice item but engraving was off center - twice!
Engraved Rosary Case
Seems like plastic